AGRICOLA PUNICA | Montessu | Isola dei Nuraghi | 2023
carignan | cabernet sauvignon | cabernet franc | merlot | syrah

© We will be evaluating wines in no particular order on no particular schedule. Just stay tuned and you will never miss our reviews. If the wine is tasted more than once, the rating table will be updated so as to reflect all the new impressions and observations. We hope you will enjoy it!

Agricola Punica is the result of a visionary collaboration, born as a joint venture between the tuscan winemaker Giacomo Tachis of Tenuta San Guido and the Cantina Santadi’s president Antonello Pilloni. This collaborative effort aims to elevate sardinian viticulture to new heights, showcasing the island’s unique terroir and grape varieties. It was Tachis who first recognized the untapped potential of Sardinia, convinced that it could yield wines of exceptional quality. In 2002, AgriPunica acquired two key estates, Barrua and Narcao, nestled in the sun-drenched southwestern corner of Sardinia, an area renowned as Basso Sulcis. From the very first harvest, the quality of the grapes confirmed Tachis’s foresight.
Today we are going to review a remarkable wine from the beautiful island of Sardinia, which is one of Italy‘s most famous wine regions – Montessu Isola dei Nuraghi 2023 by Agricola Punica. This wine was named after an ancient archaeological site near the Narcao estate, called Montessu, and represents a harmonious blend of five grape varieties, designed to showcase the power and elegance of Sardinia‘s terroir: carignan (60% – known locally as carignano, sulcis or carignano del sulcis, which is a local clone of the carignan/cariñena grape variety), cabernet sauvignon (10%), cabernet franc (10%), merlot (10%) and syrah (10%), where carignan forms the wine’s main body and brings to the forefront those dehydrated fruits notes that are characteristic of this grape variety, cabernet sauvignon enhances the wine’s structure and adds extra textural depth, cabernet franc delivers a peppery character to the wine and brings some earthiness, merlot builds a more refined mid-palate and creates a dynamic finish, while syrah is all about depth and nuance, adding that extra bit of aromatic sophistication and more color depth.

The wine is produced from the grapes sourced from the Sulcis micro-region of Sardinia (IGT Isola dei Nuraghi). The unique climate and soil of the region contribute not only to the quality of the grapes but also to the intense character of the wine. In order to soften the tannins and add a layer of extra complexity to the final blend, the wine has been aged for 12months in french oak barriques, both new and used oak, followed by 45 days of ageing in cement tanks to preserve its varietal purity and those so much desire terroir-driven notes.

Sardinia is Italy’s second-largest island and is defined by its rugged landscapes, abundant sunshine, and strong maritime influence, making it one of the Mediterranean’s most distinctive wine regions. The island enjoys a warm Mediterranean climate with long, dry summers, mild winters, and persistent coastal winds, most notably the Mistral winds, which moderate temperatures, reduce vine diseases, and prolong the ripening season. Sardinia’s diverse soils vary from granite, limestone and schist, to sandstone and sandy soils, many of which are poor and well drained, naturally limiting vine vigor and concentrating flavour in the grapes. The island is home to a wealth of indigenous grape varieties, with Cannonau being the island’s flagship grape, alongside Carignano, Monica, Vermentino, and Nuragus.
Isola dei Nuraghi is a broad geographical wine designation covering the entire island of Sardinia, named after the ancient stone nuraghe structures that are among the island’s most distinctive archaeological landmarks. Rather than being defined by a single terroir, this IGT encompasses a wide variety of landscapes, from coastal plains and rolling hills to more elevated inland areas, resulting in considerable variation in climate, soils, and wine styles. Its mediterranean climate brings long, sunny summers, mild winters, and persistent maritime winds, while soils range from granite and sandy deposits to limestone, clay, and schist. The designation allows considerable freedom in grape selection and winemaking, accommodating both Sardinia’s indigenous varieties, such as Cannonau, Carignano, Monica, Vermentino, and Nuragus, and international grapes such as Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, and Syrah.

color: medium-deep ruby color
clarity: hazy garnet hues at the rim

In the glass, the wine presents a medium-deep ruby color, offering a classic Carignan appearance. Towards the rim of the glass, hazy garnet shades emerge, hinting at the wine’s richness and concentration.

intensity: rich & vibrant
fruit character: ripe & dried

On the nose, the wine delivers a rich and fruity-vibrant aromatic profile, with a ripe to dried fruit character. It reveals a multi-layered and sophisticated aromatic tapestry, expertly balancing the inherent vibrancy of fruit with an elegant, oak-derived richness. The foreground is dominated by a lively medley of red fruits, with notes of sour cherry, red cherry, cranberry, redcurrant, and red plum, which provide a fresh and succulent core. This fruitiness is beautifully interwoven with a distinctive bouquet of mediterranean herbs, including thyme, sage, bay leaf, rosemary, and oregano, evoking the island’s aromatic scrubland. Delicate touches of clay, marl, and loam introduce a subtle earthy minerality, gracefully lifted by elegant hints of vanilla and nutmeg. As the bouquet unfurls, the background unveils deeper, more complex notes of oaky tones such as sweet tobacco, toasted oakwood, and cloves, complemented by an array of spicy undertones like peppercorn, juniper, anise, and red pepper. Subtle nuances of wood varnish, caper, and a whisper of dried cranberry add intriguing complexity, all grounded by a distinct touch of limestone, contributing to an inviting and continuously evolving aromatic experience.

sweetness: dry | acidity: high  | alcohol: high | tannin: high  | balance: good
finish: medium+ | aftertaste: crisp & seedy

On the palate, Montessu delivers a youthful yet remarkably complex mouthfeel, characterized by a pleasantly bitter-seedy texture that is both invigorating and thought-provoking. This is a spicy and fruit-forward wine – a textbook example of a well-crafted Carignan-based blend that masterfully showcases its varietal components. The mouthfeel is dry, invigorated by an exuberant acidity that provides remarkable freshness and lift, preventing any sense of heaviness. A nuanced touch of alcoholic warmth is beautifully integrated, lending depth and structure without overpowering the fruit. The tannins are ripe and seedy, coating the palate with a fine-grained, assertive grip that underscores the wine’s firm backbone and exceptional aging potential. This harmonious interplay culminates in a crisp and pleasantly bitter-seedy aftertaste that lingers, reaffirming the wine’s complexity and its deep connection to its mediterranean origins. It’s a wine that maintains a delicate balance between its bold fruit, herbaceous freshness, and subtle terroir-driven minerality.

maturity: developing | needs time | drink now or age for another 3 to 5 years
verdict: great | a benchmark wine | a wine that has all the traits to become legendary

Overall, this wine is the epitome of a modern, Carignan-based wine blend – rich, firm, and seedy – a sincere tribute dedicated to the grape variety itself. This is a wine that delivers the vibrant essence of its fruit alongside a subtle yet profound local terroir footprint. It feels well-structured, complex, and crisp, with a firm and pleasantly bitter-seedy palate. The aromatic profile is focused around grape expression and oak-derived elegance, demonstrating depth and refinement. This is a pure-bred Carignan-based wine blend vinified in a modern style, combining new-world nuance with old-world appeal. The wine is still developing, needing more time to unleash its full potential. We recommend enjoying it today for its vibrant intensity, or cellaring it for another 3 to 5 years to allow its components to fully integrate and evolve, revealing even greater harmony and finesse. Our recommendation would be to enjoy it sooner rather than later, as it is always better to drink a wine a year too soon, than a day too late.

Given its fruit-forward character and seedy tannins, this wine would make a lovely food pairing companion fir a traditional sardinian dish like ‘Agnello al Mirto‘ (lamb slow-roasted with myrtle berries and herbs) or ‘Cinghiale in Umido‘ (wild boar stew). The richness and savory depth of these meats will soften the wine’s assertive tannins, while the aromatic herbs in the dishes will beautifully harmonize with the wine’s distinct herbal and spicy notes, thus providing a delightful contrast, highlighting the wine’s complexity and inviting sip after sip. Cheers!
AGRICOLA PUNICA | Montessu | Isola dei Nuraghi | 2023
variety: carignan | cabernet sauvignon | cabernet franc | merlot | syrah
country: Italy
region: Sardinia | Isola dei Nuraghi
rating: 94.0

Agricola Punica is not just about producing outstanding wines, it stands as a symbol of the potential that Sardinia possesses in the world of winemaking, born from a joint venture between the Tenuta San Guido, sardinian winery AgriPunica, Santadi’s President Antonello Pilloni and legendary tuscan winemaker, Giacomo Tachis, who from his first visit to Sardinia, immediately realized the potential of this territory.

© The WineStatistics ratings are based solely on our own knowledge of the world of wine and on our personal wine tastes, which may, or may not, differ from yours – the reader. Just remember that there are no absolutes of right and wrong in wine appreciation. Cheers!